Is gone with the wind a classic book historically accurate

The book has been called offensive and vulgar because of the language and characterizations. Shouldnt this rule also apply to southern culture and miss mitchells classic novel. It is made possible through the cooperation of author and publisher, publisher and producer. Written from the perspective of the slaveholder, gone with the wind is southern plantation. Is gone with the wind historically accurate answers. A classic when i first read this book, i prolonged my reading experience over the course of a few months because i was enjoying it so much. Shouldn t this rule also apply to southern culture and miss mitchells classic novel. Gone with the wind dates not accurate timeline created by thornstorm14829. Gone with the wind, however, takes liberally from its authors life.

This movie was made to portray one of the most difficult times in american. The story is set in clayton county and atlanta, both in georgia, during the american civil war and reconstruction era. Inside the mansion that inspired gone with the wind. Gone with the wind will be screened in 650 theaters nationwide locally, at 2 and 7 p. Gone with the wind is an extremely atypical bigbudget studio project of its era in that it concerns itself with racial matters at all, though it blithely accepts the legitimacy of owning humans. In the comments jane pointed out, quite correctly, that the book shouldnt be taken as history, but as reflective of a very strong pointofview of american history, circa 1930. Of course, it is totally fine for older teenagers to read. To ask other readers questions about gone with the wind, please sign up. While its undeniably a long book, its swift pacing, powerful characters, and insightful observations on human nature make it well worth your time. Margaret mitchell lived her life in the south and as such was steeped in wh. How historically accurate is margaret mitchells novel.

Gone with the wind was a story of men and women living in the south during the war between the states and of the souths transformation after the war. Gone with the wind is gone from the orpheum after 34 years but the films star seems to be dimming in recent years, as its problems relative to race and american history grow harder to ignore. She is subject to the correct code of female behavior. Historical accuracy won in gone with the wind with new fuss about. I hadnt seen the movie either, so this was going to be a clean slate affair for me. Gone with the wind is a sexy book fifty shades of gray, 30s style. Gone with the wind didnt give a damn about slavery film. Margaret mitchell was a wealthy southerner, writing 70 years after the civil war. Margaret mitchells gone with the wind was enthusiastically received when it was published but it has run afoul of the sociopolitical trends of recent years. Buy a cheap copy of the complete gone with the wind trivia.

In chapter 43 mitchell gives to rhett butler a version of the speech that we know now her own mother had given her when she was a child. More than 30 million copies have been printed worldwide. Classic literature, original gangster s4 e11 gone girl by gillian flynn thug notes book summary and analysis duration. The literature police and gone with the wind abbeville institute. Gone with the wind, which was not eligible for an academy award this year since it was released in 1939, is an epic film based on a bestselling novel about how a southern white woman. Prices and availability are accurate as of the time of publication. Monday by turner classic movies and reissued tuesday in a lavish. However, i think before reading it, it is important for readers of any age to also have a good grasp of the true history regarding slavery, reconstruction, and the civil war, because much of the truth behind those events is muddled. Selznick still had no script, no leading man, and no scarlett. Gone with the wind gone with the wind is a classic movie that has been loved by many americans over many generations. Parts that reference actual civil war events are fairly accurate, but the book is a work of fiction.

Though gone with the wind is a classic now, not everyone was a fan. By all accounts, gone with the wind was a smash, garnering awards and acclaim in equal measure. Of course her analysis of the american civil war and its. Gone with the wind is generally thought to be historically accurate by critics. Gone with the wind is a novel by american writer margaret mitchell, first published in 1936. It was boredom that caused 25yearold margaret mitchell to write 63 of the most beloved chapters in literary history. Gone with the wind may be a dramatic masterpiece, but its portrayal of life during and after the civil war is not completely accurate.

Gone with the wind film, how historically accurate it was. She learns that ashley wilkes her crush is engaged to melanie hamilton. Gone with the wind, praised by trump, misrepresents. It was published in 1936, after it took her seven years to write, and won a pulitzer prize in 1937. As the movies title gone with the wind scrolled slowly across the. Gone with the wind, margaret mitchell gone with the wind is a novel by american writer margaret mitchell, first published in 1936. In that case, as in mitchells, we would not exactly be talking about ancient history. Is gone with the winds nostalgia for slavery acceptable. We like to think 1939 was a different world, a world divided from our own by a. Consequently, societys censors want the book banned. A feminist, historical analysis of gone with the wind.

The main reason for mitchells research was so that she would not have real historians and civil war veteransmore than a few of whom were still alive at the time of the book s writingcoming after her for inaccuracies. It is a great love story set in the american civil war and the period of reconstruction afterwards. If you want a more accurate portrait of slavery and emancipation. The storyline is historically accurate and the characters are brilliantly developed. As gone with the wind was an epic being filmed in technicolor, selznick demanded the costumes be sensational while remaining historically accurate. Gone with the wind is historical fiction, and the fiction is usually more important than the history. Readers will learn what brand of typewriter margaret mitchell used to type. Clark gable, vivien leigh, high res such is the magnificence of mitchells historical revisionism that. How accurate was the movie gone with the wind answers. The horrific bigotry endured by this gone with the wind. How gone with the wind took the nation by storm by. But a novel can sanitise entirely the inequities of real history.

Inside the mansion that inspired gone with the wind gone with the wind features one of the grandest homes in all of classic cinema, and now is your chance to own it or at least the home that inspired the wilkes southern plantation the movie was mostly shot on speciallybuilt set pieces. Published in 1936, margaret mitchells gone with the wind has been banned on social grounds. Historical accuracy of gone with the wind essay 1145. Margaret mitchells gone with the wind sold one million copies in its first six months, won the pulitzer prize in 1937 and brought an explosion of unexpected, unwishedfor celebrity to its author. Gone with the wind and the confederacy the atlantic. Margaret mitchell was an avid studier of the civil war, and grew up in the south listening to confederate veterans. For example in the classic 1939 film gone with the wind adapted from. Gone with the wind published margaret mitchells gone with the wind, one of the bestselling novels of all time and the basis for a blockbuster 1939 movie, is published on this day in 1936. This period in american history is known as the gilded age partially because of the ornate designs that were favored in both fashion and interior design scarlett and rhetts atlanta mansion is a prime example of the eras over the top style. Johnnys favorite part of the movie titled gone with the wind was when the gentlemen from the south rode into sure death to be gallant. A collection of everything trivia fans might want to know about a true. Many of the background elements of what life was like in georgia during the mid 19th century are very accurate, but in. Throughout history there have been political and sanctimonious types who tried to restrict what the populace is permitted to read, but in our generation these types seem to be. The classic novel shows that individual lives cannot be reduced to competing.

His112 gone with the wind directed by victor fleming. Asked in authors, poets, and playwrights, romantic movies. Does gone with the wind reflect the correct situation of. Gone with the wind sold one million copies in its first six months, won the pulitzer. In a previous post on gone with the wind i wrote that i had learned a lot about the american civil war and reconstruction, about slavery very different from uncle toms cabin and a lot about georgia and atlanta. It enjoyed a morethan30year reign as the alltime hollywood box office champion, and it won eight academy awards in addition to two honorary awards. Margaret mitchells gone with the wind was enthusiastically received. Describing the tarleton twins as long of bone and hard of muscle. In 1937, margaret mitchell won the pulitzer prize for her sweeping portrayal of the crumbling of the old south.

Based on the runaway bestselling 1936 novel gone with the wind. Gone with the wind, american epic film, released in 1939, that was one of the best known and most successful films of all time. Gone with the wind is a controversial reference point for subsequent writers of the south, both. Sunday and wednesday at cinemark and most amc theaters, broadcast at 9 p. Gone with the wind is often placed in the literary subgenre of the historical romance novel. Gone with the wind was popular with american readers from the outset and was the top american fiction bestseller in 1936 and 1937. As of 2014, a harris poll found it to be the second favorite book of american readers, just behind the bible. With this reissue of gone with the wind, i decided that it was time for me to finally read this pulitzer prize winning classic and see what all the fuss was about. Mitchells gone with the wind is one of the great novels of survival, and therein lies much of its appeal. Gone with the wind has been hailed as a triumph of american literature and film. What i ask again is, why is a book challenged for being historically accurate as in the challenge of the pillars of. An afternoon meeting miss scarlett ohara meets with stuart and brent tarleton.

Gone with the wind is a masterpiece of american literature, and highly recommended to readers of civil war fiction or those who enjoy historical drama. Gone with the wind turns 75 this year, a long enough period to establish it as an artifact, a museum piece. This lowpriced motion picture edition of gone with the wind combines the literary achievement of miss mitchells book and the cinematic triumph of its screen version, for which the publishers warmly congratulate mr. Many of the background elements of what life was like in georgia during the mid 19th century are very accurate, but in the end the book and the movie are works of fiction. What parts of the book gone with the wind were not put. One of the most beloved novels in the history of america, gone with the wind has been challengedbanned for its portrayal of the south, particularly in regards to slavesthe treatment of, negative references to, and behavior of slaves before, during, and after the civil war. Nikhil im 17 years old, so i have first hand experience in answering this. Words like damn and whore were scandalous at the time.

As its 75th anniversary approaches, gone with the wind is again being celebrated as a. I sincerely believe that this book is the number one american classic. Gone with the wind, motion picture edition, complete and. This movie was made to portray one of the most difficult times in american history. For example in the classic 1939 film gone with the wind adapted from margaret mitchells. The rerelease of the movie gone with the wind this summer prompted a new round of criticism of the movie, of the novel it is based on and of. The movie is famous for its strong lead character, scarlett ohara, but is she a true woman of her time. The literature police and gone with the wind abbeville. Also, the new york society for the suppression of vice disapproved of scarletts multiple marriages. Her entire understanding of the causes, course, and consequences of the conflict were formed and warped by that upbringing. Growing up and grasping gone with the wind it happens sometimes that you pick up a classic book expecting a great read, and youre disappointed.

In its details about dates, places and times, gone with the wind i mean the margaret mitchell novel is remarkably accurate. Historical accuracy of gone with the wind essay 1145 words. Inaccuracies the end of the war accuracies and inaccuracies of the 1939 film gone with the wind samantha shute period 4 in the story gerald ohara arrives on his plantation and announces that the civil war ended. It was directed by victor fleming, and based off of the book written by margaret mitchell. Anything regarding the dates of battles, legislation passed, and even small things like fashions in womens clothing etc, historians tend to be extremely impressed by mitchells scholarship. Learn about some of the historical inaccuracies and criticisms of the film, including its portrayal of race relations. The final third of gone with the wind 1939 occurs during the 1870s. Is gone with the wind historically accurate margaret.